Do Peasants Hold the Key to Humanity’s Future? - Jacobin

Do Peasants Hold the Key to Humanity’s Future? - Jacobin

Do Peasants Hold the Key to Humanity’s Future?

A new book attempts to revive interest in peasants by casting them as humanity’s last defenders against ecological catastrophe. However, this perspective misrepresents the peasantry’s relationships to both nature and economic development.

In 1966, sociologist Teodor Shanin asserted that “peasants are the majority of mankind.” This declaration sparked a decades-long surge in academic interest in the peasantry, which, alongside its demographic significance, fueled significant political movements in the 20th century. Works like anthropologist Eric Wolf’s Peasant Wars of the Twentieth Century documented subsistence farmers' global activism.

Since Shanin’s statement, world agriculture has undergone profound transformations. Large-scale, highly mechanized farms have boosted productivity and output. Smallholder agriculture has embraced Green Revolution technologies, including synthetic fertilizers, high-yielding crops, and pesticides. A continuous exodus of farmers has contributed to urban growth in both rich and poor nations.

The global countryside’s dramatic overhaul has led to a decline in the peasantry’s academic focus. Historian Eric Hobsbawm characterized the 20th century as the “death of the peasantry,” a view echoed in recent literature.

Maryam Aslany’s Peasants: Makers of the Modern World challenges this conventional wisdom, asserting that reports of the peasantry’s death have been exaggerated. She claims there are currently two billion peasants, producing a third of the world’s food. Drawing from her fieldwork in India, Cambodia, Peru, and Ghana, Aslany aims to restore the countryside’s visibility.

Aslany considers the peasantry’s crisis as the most significant story of the 21st century. She believes peasants are humanity’s ultimate guardians against ecological disaster, attributing to them a sacred connection to nature and a unique ability to manage natural resources. She argues that progressive urban forces threaten this vital role, and humanity’s survival depends on supporting and strengthening the peasantry. She also foresees future urban overcrowding leading to repeasantization.

However, Aslany’s revisionist take on the peasantry has critical flaws. Her historical account of global development confuses states and peasants’ roles. She overestimates the peasantry’s future significance. Furthermore, her argument that peasants hold a unique solution to environmental problems is unconvincing.

What Is a Peasant?

Aslany’s claim of two billion peasants is from her article, where she makes a slightly different statement—that the rural populations of three less-developed continents comprise this number.

Leave a Reply