Hard times on the farm - Rochester Beacon

Getting your Trinity Audio Player Ready

In late July, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) accepted a request from Gov. Kathy Hochul to designate disaster aid for farmers whose crops were damaged by adverse weather conditions in the spring.

“New York’s growers are second to none and many have taken a significant hit, with some reporting upwards of a 100% loss of their crop and millions in economic loss,” Hochul stated in her request. “This hardship follows a trend we are becoming all too familiar with—temperature swings indicative of our changing climate.”

However, as Craig Kahlke, team leader at the Lake Ontario Fruit Program (which covers over 30,000 acres of apple crops), notes, rising costs, flat market prices, and labor shortages are also significant challenges:

“If you have a year where you get a hailstorm that wipes out two-thirds of your farm, guess what? Climate change is the most important thing. But it’s more prices and returns that are starting to push growers out of business at the moment than it is climate change, although that certainly doesn’t help.”

The Finger Lakes region, a major agricultural hub in New York State, brings in approximately $2.34 billion annually, leading the state in agricultural sales. It boasts almost half of the state’s total farmland, the highest concentration of wineries, and the bulk of the state’s apple production.

Despite this, many area farmers are struggling to stay afloat.

Overhead Costs and Thin Profit Margins

Running a farm is a demanding endeavor, with high overhead costs including labor, equipment, management, fertilizer, pesticides, and more. Farmers often have limited access to their wealth, as profits typically get reinvested back into operations. The average crop farm spent over $250,000 in 2024, according to the USDA’s National Agricultural Statistic Service.

Economic Pressures

Recent global events have exacerbated the situation:

  • COVID-19 Pandemic: Led to supply chain disruptions and increased costs.
  • Conflict in Iran: Skyrocketed fertilizer and fuel prices.

Meanwhile, crop prices haven’t kept pace, widening the gap between received and paid prices since mid-2023. Many farmers report years of operating at a loss.

“Most growers across the board, even field crop, field seed, processing, vegetables, they’re all not making money. They’re dipping into their reserves in order to farm,” says Stephanie Craft of G&S Orchards.

Kendra Burnap, a generational farmer from Sodus, agrees:

“My father started this farm 40 years ago. He was getting 11 cents a pound from Mott’s for apples. They just came out with their price at 17 cents a pound this year. That’s 6 cents above where it was 40 years ago, yet the cost to grow those apples has increased 20-fold.”

Challenges for Apple Growers

Apple growers face an especially difficult market:

“The apple market is the most difficult to get prices that farmers can survive with,” says Burnap.

Many farmers lack control over their pricing, further complicating their financial situation.

Leave a Reply