Purina & Farm Journal: Unclear ROI Blocks Regenerative Farms
Interest in regenerative agriculture is on the rise among procurement leaders, as food and beverage enterprises seek to:
- Strengthen supply chain resilience
- Reduce Scope 3 emissions
- Develop sustainable sourcing strategies.
Supporting farmers in transitioning to more sustainable practices, however, presents challenges beyond corporate sustainability commitments.
Research by Farm Journal Intelligence, commissioned by Purina PetCare (a Nestlé brand), reveals a gap between farmers' positive perceptions of regenerative agriculture and their willingness or ability to implement it.
Kelsey Ryan, Regenerative Agriculture Lead for Purina North America, emphasizes the importance of creating programs that work for farmers: "As a leader, I’m focused on helping to create programs that work for farmers today, to build a foundation for the future."
For businesses dependent on agricultural commodities, the question arises: how can procurement teams make sustainable farming commercially attractive while protecting supply continuity and controlling costs?
Some key findings from the research:
- 45% of farmers adopt conservation practices when they see a return on investment.
- 41% would be convinced to adopt regenerative practices by evidence of positive results from similar operations.
- 70% only try new practices after seeing other farmers implement them.
- 65% cite rising input prices and crop underperformance as factors that could make them reconsider farming practices.
- 33% of farmers who didn't adopt or continue regenerative practices listed lack of time as a primary barrier.
Regenerative Agriculture’s Adoption Gap
Regenerative agriculture encompasses practices aimed at restoring and enhancing agricultural ecosystem health, particularly soil health, biodiversity, and water management.
For food procurement leaders, these practices can contribute to more resilient farming systems and support enterprise sustainability goals.
The research, which surveyed 510 US commercial farmers growing corn, rice, soy, and wheat, highlights a significant gap between positive attitudes towards regenerative agriculture and its practical implementation.
Emily Johannes, Senior Vice President of Farm Journal’s Trust in Food initiative, notes: "Farmers are balancing their interest in regenerative and conservation practices with the realities of running an operation today, from uncertain markets to the cost of trying something new."
While 88% of farmers under 45 expressed favorable views of regenerative agriculture, only 46% were enrolled in regenerative or conservation agriculture programs. Among older farmers, program participation reached 54%.
The generational divide is notable. If younger farmers continue to struggle adopting sustainable practices, the future of regenerative agriculture may be at risk.
Financial and operational barriers to adoption include time pressures (33% of respondents) and the cost of transitioning, which requires investment in new equipment and training, with financial benefits potentially taking several growing seasons to materialize.
Can Supplier Collaboration Boost Sustainability Scaling?
Deloitte and PepsiCo’s broader research further emphasizes the importance of collaboration between suppliers and brands in driving sustainability progress.