Getting your Trinity Audio Player Ready: A County's Journey Towards Rural Zoning Balance
After a significant public backlash from farmers, winery owners, and equestrians, Santa Clara County officials took a step back and reassessed their proposed rural zoning amendment in September 2025. This led to the formation of an Agricultural Advisory Committee in October, at the request of District 1 Supervisor Sylvia Arenas and the county's Housing, Land Use, Environment, and Transportation Committee.
The 10-person committee, comprising representatives from various agricultural and community sectors, has held three meetings—on October 8, October 22, and most recently on November 10—to provide insights to the county's Department of Planning and Development. All meetings are open to the public, with further public engagement planned. Residents can also submit comments to contribute to the development of the new draft plan.
Kim Engelhardt, a committee member and owner of Lion Ranch Vineyards, expressed confidence in the committee's role:
"We as a committee are a sounding board for county planning to understand unintended consequences... We need to talk about this early to ensure it works for farmers and the agriculture industry. I anticipate a lengthy process."
Supervisor Arenas emphasized the importance of public input, stating:
"Hundreds of farmers, winery owners, equestrians, and residents voiced their concerns last year... This hard work must result in changes that benefit agricultural businesses and our community."
The committee includes experts from diverse fields, such as Anna Regalado from the Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority, Jeff Martin from Frantoio Grove, Greg Bozzo, the Gilroy Mayor, and Joe Raineri from Terra Amico. Other members are Paul Kermoyan (P&V Winery), Rachael Parakh (Santa Clara County Horseman’s Association), Rebecca Garcia (Santa Clara County Housing Authority), Stephen McHenry (Lone Oak Equestrian Center), and Bill James (Cattlemen’s Association, Santa Clara County Farm Bureau, and Loma Prieta Resource Conservation District).
Patrick McGarrity, a spokesperson for Supervisor Arenas' office, explained the challenges with the existing code:
"The code is updated infrequently, and when it is, it’s often a partial change... There were issues with the 'local serving' term, leading to litigation and appeals. This new draft aims to treat everyone fairly and preserve agriculture while updating the zoning codes comprehensively."
The revised draft has three key objectives: to replace the "local serving" provisions with objective standards.