Dive Brief: Compostable Packaging and the BPI's Advocacy
Compostable Packaging in Organic Agriculture
The Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) is defending its efforts to promote compostable packaging for organic agriculture. They have been petitioning the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) for this change.
New Coalition Against BPI
Last week, a coalition, Safer Soils for All, formed to counter BPI's campaign. This coalition includes major haulers and the California Compost Coalition, arguing that compostable packaging presents challenges for composters.
BPI's Response
BPI's Executive Director, Rhodes Yepsen, refuted the coalition's claims, stating they are merely "the waste industry dressed up in composter clothing." He emphasized that BPI aims to allow compostable products in organic agriculture, not forcing composters to accept them.
Supporting BPI's Petition
Several compost operators, including Black Earth Compost, Blue Earth Compost, and Garbage to Garden, signed a letter supporting BPI's petition to the USDA. This letter requested an interim final rule on the compost definition, triggering a public comment period.
USDA's Response and Future Plans
The USDA has not commented on BPI's petition but plans to gather more information through an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking early next year.
Yepsen's Counterargument
Yepsen argues that the new coalition distracts from investments in depackaging and processing equipment for agricultural products from waste, rather than compost. He asserts that their concerns are unrelated to organic farmers or compostable products.
California's AB 1201
The debate is particularly focused on California, the nation's largest compost market. AB 1201, passed in 2021, would restrict products not approved for organic agriculture from using the "compostable" label. Packagers worry this could hinder the market for compostable products.
Slurry Processing and Contamination
Some companies process food waste into a slurry for anaerobic digestion. Yepsen expresses concerns about potential contaminants in the slurry, but he attributes these issues to infrastructure and education, not compostable products.
BPI's Compostability Standard
Yepsen defended BPI's compostability standard, which allows products to biodegrade in up to 180 days, stating that this is determined in laboratory conditions and products typically break down faster in commercial compost. He suggests measuring composting success by compost maturity rather than time.
AB 1201's Impact
As for AB 1201, the text does not provide further insights, leaving this part as a reference to the broader discussion.