Shapiro hears from farmers on workforce crisis tied to ICE enforcement - PennLive.com

Shapiro hears from farmers on workforce crisis tied to ICE enforcement - PennLive.com

Update

This post was updated at 9:49 a.m. Friday with some statistics on how the federal government’s uptick in ICE detentions has played out in Pennsylvania.

Governor Josh Shapiro's Focus on Immigration Policy

Gov. Josh Shapiro’s schedule contained a bit of an oddity Thursday. The governor, known for his mantra “Getting Stuff Done,” spent much of his afternoon on an issue where he has limited authority, primarily asking “what can I do?” That issue? Immigration policy, which Shapiro understands is primarily the domain of the federal government.

On a beautiful fall day, his gubernatorial SUV caravaned to Marietta, Lancaster County, to learn more about the impact of President Donald J. Trump’s high-profile deportation policy on Pennsylvania’s food producers.

Here are some key takeaways:

  • Agriculture's Dependence on Immigrants: Even in Pennsylvania, agriculture is a highly immigration-dependent industry. According to the National Agricultural Workers Survey, approximately 61% of hired crop workers in the U.S. are foreign-born, with over 40% being unauthorized.

  • Farmers' Concerns: Pennsylvania farmers and producers are worried about the impact of ICE raids and enforcement. Sarah Lott Zost, a fourth-generation fruit grower in Adams County, shared her experiences, stating, "There’s a culture of fear and concern because you get targeted because of what you look like... Many workers stay home out of fear of being targeted."

  • Statistical Surge in Detentions: Stats from the Deportation Data Project show a significant surge in Pennsylvania's detentions with arrest in 2026, reaching 5,489 statewide, compared to 3,234 in 2025 and 764 in 2024 (the last year of the Biden Administration).

  • Critical Labor Dependence: Brent Hershey, from Hershey Ag pork farm, expressed his constant worry about the labor shortage, as his farm relies heavily on foreign-born workers for tasks like moving weaned piglets. He emphasized the critical nature of timely labor for piglet births, stating, "If the workforce isn’t there, ... the next day we have pigs die."

  • Proposed Solutions: Roundtable participants offered suggestions for Gov. Shapiro, primarily advocating for federal law changes or policy shifts. Brad Wagner, CEO of the Lancaster-based Wenger Group, proposed more proactive enforcement methods, such as open-door ICE inspections of employers' records.

Zost also suggested immediate relief, stating, "an end to the 'no-tolerance' policy and a path to citizenship for those here for a significant period of time."

Leave a Reply